Burke’s motive – from text to society

Authors

  • Tanja Juul Christiansen University of Copenhagen
  • Anne Werner Løhndorf University of Copenhagen

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52610/rhs.v11i42.197

Keywords:

Rhetoric, union communication, solidarity, identification, dramatism, Burke, motive

Abstract

Motive is a key term in Kenneth Burke’s theory of Dramatism. With the concept of motive Burke moves away from the traditional focus of intention and thereby makes it possible to not only analyze an artefact at hand, but also the society that the artefact reflects. However, the question still remains: how does the critic identify motive in the artefact – and what makes the step from artefact to society possible? Using the Dramatism of Kenneth Burke, this article analyzes the members’ magazines of two Danish unions with the purpose of identifying their underlying motives. Both unions create consubstantiality – though by very different motives. One union through the motive of a scene-agent ratio, the other through the motive of an act-agent ratio: two different motives that both show in the society as cultural ideologies. However different the motives are, they are equally strong and unchallenged throughout all issues of the analyzed magazines. The article finally argues that even though the motives represent ideologies in the society, monocentric motives as the ones identified might be problematic in the future.

Author Biographies

Tanja Juul Christiansen, University of Copenhagen

Tanja Juul Christiansen er ligeledes cand. mag. i retorik og medejer af konsulentvirksomheden Mærkbar Retorik. Tanja underviser desuden på Institut for Medier, Erkendelse og Formidling på Københavns Universitet og på Institut for Internationale Kultur- og Kommunikationsstudier på CBS.

Anne Werner Løhndorf, University of Copenhagen

Anne Werner Løhndorf er cand. mag. i retorik. Hun er medejer af konsulentvirksomheden Mærkbar Retorik og underviser desuden i retorik ved Den Grafiske Højskole, Suhrs Seminarium samt Københavns Universitet.

References

Andersen, Pernille T. (2004): ”Arbejdsliv, alliancer og ambivalenser – En analyse af yngre ufaglærte kvinders syn på fagbevægelsen.” . I: Tidsskrift for arbejdsliv. Tema: Fagbevægelsen under forandring. 6. årgang nr. 3, s. 27-45, september 2004. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7146/tfa.v6i3.108419

Brummett, Barry (1993):“Introduction. Landmark Essays on Kenneth Burke.” Landmark Essays. On Kenneth Burke. Vol. 2, 1993. Red.: Barry Brummett. Hermagoras Press.

Burke, Kenneth (1969a): A Grammar of Motives. (1945). University of California Press. California edition.

– (1969b): A Rhetoric of Motives. (1950). University of California Press. California. Paperback, California edition.

– (1968): “Dramatism.” I: International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. S. 446-452. Macmillan.

– (1966): Language as Symbolic Action. University of California Press.

– (1964): Permanence and Chance. An Anatomy of Purpose. (1935). Hermes Publications. Second revised edition, second printing.

– (1973): The Philosophy of Literary Form. (1941). University of California Press. Third edition, revised.

Foss, Sonja mfl. (1991): “Kenneth Burke.” I: Contemporary Perspectives on Rhetoric. Kapitel 7, s. 169-207. Waveland Press, Inc.

Ling, David A. (1989): ”A pentadic analysis of E. Kennedy’s Address to the people of Massachusetts July 25, 1969”. I: Rhetorical Criticism. S. 344-351. Waveland Press, Inc.

Løhndorf, Anne og Christiansen, Tanja (2005): To verdener, to motiver – samme form for samhørighed.En dramatistisk kritik af hvordan fagforeninger skaber samhørighed i en hyperkompleks verden. Speciale fra Københavns Universitet 15. maj 2005.

Qvortrup, Lars (2000): Det hyperkomplekse samfund. (1998). Nordisk Forlag A/S.

Qvortrup, Lars (2001): Det lærende samfund. Nordisk Forlag A/S.

Valentin, Michael (2002): Bare det holder min tid ud. Fagbevægelsen - fortid eller fremtid? Aschehoug Dansk Forlag A/S.

DJØF: DJØF 2009. www.djoef.dk

Djøfbladet (2004): djøfbladet. Nr. 5, 7, 11, 15, 17 og 19. Udgivet af DJØF.

Fagbladet (2004): fagbladet. Nr. 1, 5,13,17,19 og 23. Udgivet af SiD.

Hjemmesider: www.djoef.dk og www.3f.dk

Downloads

Published

2025-12-16

How to Cite

Juul Christiansen, T., & Werner Løhndorf, A. (2025). Burke’s motive – from text to society. Rhetorica Scandinavica, 11(42), 32–48. https://doi.org/10.52610/rhs.v11i42.197